Land and sea use change

Human activity has significantly altered at least 87% of the area of the ocean, and is directly linked to the destruction of ocean habitats and marine biodiversity. This is both the result of actions on land and at sea.

The clearance of land for agricultural expansion, for example, is felt in seas thousands of miles away. Runoff from pesticides and fertilisers enter ocean-bound waterways, disrupting the pH balance of underwater ecosystems and contributing to climate-change-accelerating marine eutrophication. This can be seen in the expansive – and expanding – Great Atlantic Sargassum Belt, an overabundant bloom of seaweed caused by agricultural runoff, climate change, and pollution which is currently threatening marine wildlife and human health alike.

Marine ecosystems are negatively impacted by coastal and underwater critical infrastructure development such as subsea communication cables. Our current linear model also indirectly impacts our ocean spaces as bigger shipments of more material goods require bigger ships to be built and expanded ports for them to sail into. The sea is used, too, as a setting for water desalination and marine energy technologies; each, to varying degrees, disrupt habitats and displace the species that rely on them.

Overexploitation

In 2019, humanity was using nature and its resources at rates 1.75 times faster than the planet’s ecosystems can regenerate. This overexploitation is a direct and indirect consequence of our current take-make-waste economy. 

The land-based extraction of the earth’s resources beyond the realms of nature’s own replenishment cycles has many indirect climate impacts on ocean health. In addition, the overexploitation of flora and fauna on land also has corresponding impacts on ocean ecosystems. Loss of tree cover from extensive deforestation, for example, causes topsoil to run into streams, rivers, and ultimately the ocean. Studies show that these sedimentation responses to deforestation also trigger land-to-ocean transportation of organic matter which has a negative impact on the stability of marine biogeochemical cycles. 

Deforestation is hard to miss; the decimation of land-based ecosystems is widely felt and extensively seen in everything from media coverage to school geography textbooks.

At sea, overexploitation is, while less visible, no less extensive.

Fish are often the first thought: the Global Fishing Index estimates that worldwide fish stocks have been depleted to less than 40% of their pre-industrial fishing population. Other experts suggest the loss could be even greater. Much of this loss has been fuelled by destructive practices such as deep ocean trawling – an indiscriminate method of industrial fishing that has an enormous negative impact on ocean sediment and marine habitats.

Beyond food, humans extract vast amounts of materials from the ocean. As well as the obvious – such as offshore drilling for crude oil – many other industries overexploit the ocean’s resources: from aquatic organisms used for nutraceuticals (marine-derived health and beauty products including collagen supplements) to minerals and metals which supply everyday electronics. 

Ocean spaces are more frequently being looked to for materials cultivation. As land-based sources run low, deep sea phosphate reserves are being mined to sustain the conventional global agricultural system. Meanwhile, sand and marine aggregates are dredged from seabeds to be turned into concrete, transport infrastructure, and glass. The adverse impacts of excavations span multiple scales: from the loss of specific species and physical damage of marine ecosystems which provide essential climate regulating services, to the release of harmful contaminants into the water column. 

Climate change

Anthropogenic climate change is already evident in the temperatures, movement patterns, oxygen saturation, acidity, and sea levels of our one global ocean, causing coastal darkening, coral bleaching, and many impacts in between. Each emission-driven symptom has a corresponding root cause in the linear economy.

Almost half of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions are a result of the way we produce and use materials, including food; the rest come from the ways we produce energy. The linear food system alone is responsible for the release of over a third of all anthropogenic GHG emissions. Physical distance from the ocean is irrelevant: sprawling Kansas cattle farms, vast central China rice fields, and giant food processing plants in Brazil each threaten marine biodiversity and ecosystem function through the emissions they generate. 

As it is on land, so it is at sea. 

Although industrial farming of fish and aquatic organisms has fewer direct GHG emissions than other animal proteins – equivalent to 4% of global food production – there are other indirect emissions. For example, a major ingredient of the feed required to sustain the 214 million tonnes of fisheries and aquaculture output is soybean – one of the world’s largest single crop contributors to climate change. Meanwhile, the diet of livestock – including methane-producing Kansas cattle as well as other farmed animals – are sometimes supplemented with fishmeal protein. Similarly, Chinese rice paddies may be fortified with fertiliser extracted from underwater sedimentary phosphate reserves off the Gulf of Mexico. Each example further highlights the land–ocean interconnections. 

Pollution

Waste and pollution are symptoms of the linear economy. 

Plastics are a prominent land-based example. Approximately 11 million tonnes of plastic end up in the ocean each year; an amount expected to nearly triple by 2040. Seven years ago, research warned that, without urgent systems transformation, there would be more plastic than fish in the sea by 2050. At the latest scientific estimate, there are now thought to be over 170 trillion plastic particles floating in the world’s ocean.

Other pollutants pervade and persist too. Novel entities – the collective name given to the planetary boundary of chemical pollution – from land-based industry, mining, and agriculture have devastating consequences on water quality as they wash down into the sea, disrupting habitats and further contributing to the breakdown of marine ecosystems. 

Pollution can also flow in the opposite direction.

It can occur at sea and impact aquatic and terrestrial environments alike. Offshore drilling for oil and gas releases high levels of GHG emissions and other air pollutants into the atmosphere, damaging the entire planetary system. Nutrient pollution discharged from industrial aquaculture, for example, can cause localised algal blooms which are toxic to humans and animals as well as marine life. 

Invasive alien species

The ability of the ocean to function as the planet’s ecological support system is threatened by the unintentional introduction – and then uncontrolled spread – of species that are not native to a particular area. In the wrong place, these species can disrupt the ecological balance by dominating vulnerable ecosystems, degrading water quality, spreading diseases, and in the worst case triggering extinctions. 

Some invasive alien species spread across the ocean on the products of the linear economy: marine litter acts as a vector for mollusc migration and man-made flotsam enables the long-distance rafting of coral polyps from one ecosystem to another. As 90% of the world’s goods travel across the ocean surface, so do bits of biodiversity: from algae hitchhiking on ship hulls to crustaceans being forcibly migrated from one area of the ocean and expelled into another via ballast water. 

It’s not just marine organisms that make these unwitting transoceanic journeys. Land-based insects and pests, too, travel on the material trappings of a linear economy, threatening the terrestrial ecosystems of their final destination. 

Other introductions are intentional, even if the consequences are not.

Global aquaculture is a fast-growing supply sector; industrial scale operations that intensively farm non-native species without considering the impact on local waters risk the accidental spread of invasive alien species which can dominate and disrupt the delicate balance of surrounding ecosystems.